-3.png?width=50&name=Square%20(2)-3.png)
Exclusive insights from The Financial Coconut's conversation with MOF Budget Directors Ming Jing and John Koh reveal the art of national budgeting – and surprisingly practical lessons for your personal finances.
In a rare peek behind the curtain of Singapore's fiscal machinery, The Financial Coconut recently sat down with Ministry of Finance Budget Directors Ming Jing and John for an illuminating 41-minute conversation that revealed not just how our national budget comes together, but also timeless principles about money management that apply whether you're running a country or planning your household finances.
The Hidden Budget: It's Not What You Think
Before diving into the meaty insights, John delivered a reality check that should reframe how we think about Singapore's annual budget announcements: "PM delivers the statement on February 18, and that actually is basically, kind of like the highlights of the Budget... But that's not the whole Budget. Actually, the whole budget is the $140 billion that is impossible to cover in a 90-minute speech."
The Budget Book runs over 300 pages, and what captures public attention – those vouchers and immediate relief measures everyone debates about – represents merely 5% of total government spending. The remaining 95% goes toward the unglamorous but essential: infrastructure, education, healthcare, defence, and long-term strategic investments.
It's rather like looking at someone's financial health by only examining their weekend splurges whilst ignoring their mortgage payments, CPF contributions, and insurance premiums. The real story lies in the foundations.
The Feedback Loop: How Policy Actually Changes
One of the most striking revelations was how responsive Singapore's budgeting process actually is to public feedback. Ming Jing provided a concrete example with SkillsFuture:
"Soon after [the Budget 2025 announcement], feedback started coming in, 'Hey, actually, I don't want to take the full-time programme. The opportunity cost is too high if I just want to do a part-time...' and actually, then the process started almost immediately after the Budget last year to look into this, and to see whether a part-time option could be offered."
The lesson here isn't just about responsive governance – it's about the importance of systematic feedback in any financial system. Just as the government conducts closed-door sessions with experts and public consultations, your personal financial planning benefits from regular reviews with advisors, family discussions, and honest assessment of what's working and what isn't.
More about this episode
The Voucher Debate: Why Not Just Give Cash?
The perennial question about why Singapore issues vouchers rather than direct cash transfers received a surprisingly nuanced answer from John: "The advantage of vouchers over cash is that it can also support our heartland merchants and our hawkers. Because if you give cash, what can Singaporeans do? You can save in a bank, go Japan... it leaves our borders and we can't do much about it."
This reveals a sophisticated understanding of money flows and multiplier effects. The government isn't just providing relief – it's strategically directing spending to support the local economy. It's the fiscal equivalent of buying local produce rather than imported goods: your money stays within your community's ecosystem.
For individuals, this translates to thinking beyond immediate gratification when making financial decisions. Consider the broader impacts: supporting local businesses, investing in your community, and understanding how your spending patterns create ripple effects.
The Household Unit Principle: Family as Financial Foundation
Ming Jing's explanation of why many policies use household rather than individual income for means testing revealed a fundamental philosophy: "We still want to actually nurture the family as the first line of support for Singaporeans... The state can only do so much."
This isn't just policy wonkery – it's recognition that families are natural financial risk-sharing mechanisms. "When you receive help from the family, I still think it feels better than receiving something from the state," Ming Jing observed.
The personal finance implications are profound. In an era where individual financial independence is often emphasised, Singapore's approach reminds us that family financial planning – shared resources, mutual support during difficult periods, and collective long-term planning – remains one of the most effective financial strategies available.
The Art of Prioritisation: 95% Foundation, 5% Response
Perhaps the most valuable insight for personal financial management came from understanding how Singapore balances long-term strategic investments against short-term responsive measures. John explained their approach: "There's quite a big proportion of a budget that is decided... where the BAU [business as usual] keep the lights on, type of thing."
For new priorities, they use a competitive "reinvestment fund" where proposals are evaluated based on their theory of change, expected outcomes, and alignment with strategic priorities.
Apply this to your personal finances:
- Foundation first: Ensure your "BAU" – emergency funds, insurance, retirement contributions, basic living expenses – is solid before chasing new investment opportunities
- Strategic allocation: When you do have surplus to deploy, evaluate opportunities based on clear criteria and expected outcomes
- Responsive flexibility: Keep a small portion (perhaps that 5%) for opportunistic investments or addressing immediate needs
The Uncertainty Premium: Preparing for Unknown Unknowns
Ming Jing acknowledged the growing uncertainty in today's world: "There is truth in the fact that things are getting more uncertain, so not only in the job market, there's AI... your geopolitical situation is getting worse."
Their response? Continuous evolution of social safety nets – from the introduction of CPF Life to MediShield Life to the new Job Seeker Support Scheme. "We are open to see whether there's a need to do more. I think, never say never."
For individuals facing similar uncertainty, this suggests building multiple layers of protection rather than relying on any single strategy. Diversify your income sources, enhance your skills continuously, maintain strong family and professional networks, and keep your financial plans adaptable.
The GST Reality: Progressivity in Disguise
John's revelation about GST was particularly eye-opening: "The interesting thing about GST is that most of our GST revenue comes from foreigners, foreign tourists, high income... 50% of net GST collected, which is GST minus our GST Voucher, half of that is contributed by foreigners and foreign tourists."
This reframes the GST debate entirely. What appears regressive on paper becomes progressive in practice through both the voucher system and spending patterns. High earners and visitors contribute disproportionately, whilst lower-income Singaporeans receive offsetting support.
The personal finance lesson: look beyond surface-level impacts to understand the full system. That expensive insurance premium might seem burdensome until you consider the protection it provides. That higher-cost investment platform might be worthwhile if it offers better long-term returns.
Building Resilience Through Systematic Thinking
The conversation revealed that Singapore's fiscal success stems not from any single brilliant policy, but from systematic thinking about trade-offs, feedback loops, and long-term sustainability. As Ming Jing noted, "Social spending has doubled," yet the system remains financially sustainable because of disciplined prioritisation and diversified revenue streams.
The directors emphasised that effective budgeting – whether national or personal – requires:
- Clear principles (family support, long-term thinking, sustainable financing)
- Regular feedback and adjustment (monitoring what works, changing what doesn't)
- Strategic patience (investing in foundations before pursuing opportunities)
- Diversified approaches (multiple tools for multiple objectives)
The Never Say Never Principle
Perhaps most importantly, both directors demonstrated intellectual humility about future possibilities. On wealth taxes, Ming Jing said, "As a good policy maker, you should never be closed to ideas. So I think the Ministry of Finance is always in this phase of discovery and thinking ahead on what's next? How can we improve the system?"
This openness to evolving strategies based on changing circumstances is perhaps the most valuable lesson for personal finance. The best financial plan is not the one that's perfect from day one, but the one that can adapt whilst maintaining its core principles.
Applying National Wisdom to Personal Finance
The conversation with Singapore's budget directors offers a masterclass in applied financial thinking that transcends the scale of application. Whether you're managing a $143 billion national budget or your monthly household finances, the principles remain remarkably consistent:
Build strong foundations before pursuing optimisations. Listen to feedback and adapt accordingly. Think systematically about trade-offs and multiplier effects. Maintain strategic patience whilst staying responsive to changing circumstances. And perhaps most importantly, remember that the most visible financial decisions are often the least significant – it's the quiet, consistent, long-term choices that determine ultimate success.
In a world of increasing uncertainty and complexity, Singapore's approach offers a roadmap: disciplined, adaptive, principled, and always willing to evolve. These aren't just lessons for policymakers – they're wisdom for anyone serious about building lasting financial resilience.
Let us know what you think about this topic, and what do you want to hear next.
You can now be our community contributor and make a pitch to have your favourite personality be on our show.
Join our community group and drop us your insights on this topic.
Let us know what you think of this post