Skip to content

Niu Lai: A $3,000 Film Just Out-Earned Most AI-Generated Movies

Picture of The Financial Coconut
Follow The Financial Coconut

 

Niu Lai, a Chinese animated film mocked online as "worse than AI", was made for a few thousand yuan and has since grossed more than US$2.1 million (about S$2.7 million). That beats what most AI-generated films manage on similar or larger budgets. But the lesson isn't "make things cheaply." It's how rare this outcome actually is.

 

What Niu Lai actually cost, and what it earned

Niu Lai ("Here Comes the Ox") was made almost entirely by a mother-and-son team, Xin Yumeng and Sun Lifang, over five years, at a company that used to do interior decoration. Wikipedia records the cost as "a few thousand renminbi", with one widely circulated estimate putting it nearer ¥20,000 to ¥30,000, roughly S$3,800 to S$5,700. There was no trailer, no press tour, just a single ink-wash poster.

For its first nine days in theatres, that investment earned precisely ¥7,169 (about S$1,360) from 236 viewers. Then clips of its stiff, amateurish animation went viral, not despite looking cheap, but because it visibly wasn't AI. Chinese social media framed it as the anti-slop antidote to a year of hyper-polished, machine-generated content. Box office takings then exploded, crossing ¥14.9 million (roughly US$2.1 million) and still climbing, placing it among 2026's highest-grossing Chinese animated releases.

How that stacks up against AI-generated video

The comparison Singapore creators actually want is against AI content, since "cheap production" is assumed to be an AI story by default. It isn't, at least not reliably.

Take Dreams of Violets, a 75-minute feature made entirely with AI tools (no cameras, actors or sets) by studio Fountain 0. It cost US$2,000 (about S$2,560), similar magnitude to Niu Lai's budget, and became the first fully AI-generated film accepted into a major festival, premiering at Tribeca in June 2026. Its payoff was prestige and industry access, not box office revenue; no commercial gross has been reported.

Or take Huo Qubing, an AI-generated Chinese short drama reportedly costing just ¥3,000 (about S$570) in computing alone, which reached 500 million views. But views aren't profit. China's short-drama sector, now worth over ¥120 billion a year, has thin monetisation: some studios cite payouts as low as ¥5 to ¥10 per 10,000 views, prompting one production head to halt hiring, saying "such revenue cannot achieve profitability." Applied loosely to Huo Qubing's view count, that is tens of thousands of dollars at best, a fraction of what Niu Lai earned from a fraction of the audience. Vendor estimates put general AI short-film costs between US$75 and US$5,000: cheap, but that doesn't automatically buy an audience willing to pay.

The real lesson: cheap doesn't create demand, a genuinely rare story does

Niu Lai's numbers are extraordinary precisely because they're atypical. For every viral outlier, there are thousands of similarly low-cost projects, AI-made or handmade, earning close to nothing. What moved the needle was a narrative creators can't manufacture on demand: unmistakable, unpolished authenticity landing exactly when audiences were fatigued by AI sameness.

That is the same pattern behind other low-cost, high-variance bets TFC has looked at, like the psychology behind Pop Mart's blind boxes, where a small stake occasionally pays off spectacularly and that rare payoff is what keeps people chasing the next one. Treating a viral outlier as a repeatable strategy is the mistake, whether the stake is a video budget or a punt on the next hot stock.

For Singapore side hustlers weighing content as income, the more useful question isn't "how cheap can I make this." It's whether the underlying craft and distribution can survive the near-certain outcome of nothing going viral, which is closer to how we thinks about building side income that compounds rather than one that hinges on a lightning strike.

FAQ

  1. How much did Niu Lai cost to make?
    Reports put the budget at "a few thousand renminbi," with one estimate citing roughly ¥20,000 to ¥30,000 (about S$3,800 to S$5,700), spent over five years by a two-person crew.

  2. Was Niu Lai made using AI?
    No. It was hand-animated, and its rough, non-AI look became central to why it went viral, as a contrast to polished AI-generated content.

  3. How much does it cost to make an AI-generated short film or movie?
    Figures vary widely, from under US$200 for short AI clips to US$2,000 for a full-length feature like Dreams of Violets, depending on length and tools used.

  4. Can AI-generated videos go viral and make real money like Niu Lai did?
    They can go viral. Huo Qubing reached 500 million views on a reported ¥3,000 compute cost. But views don't equal profit; typical short-drama monetisation is thin, so high view counts don't guarantee anywhere near Niu Lai's box office return.

Want the maths on side income that compounds instead of relying on a viral fluke? The Financial Coconut unpacks it in this piece on side hustles accelerating FIRE. For the psychology behind why cheap, high-variance bets are so addictive, TFC's breakdown of Pop Mart's blind boxes is worth a read. For clearer-headed entrepreneurial and investing bets, explore The Financial Coconut's Business and Invest verticals.

Let us know what you think about this topic, and what do you want to hear next.

You can now be our community contributor and make a pitch to have your favourite personality be on our show.
Join our community group and drop us your insights on this topic.

References

  1. Cartoon Brew, Chinese Feature 'Niu Lai' Became A Surprise Viral Box Office Hit

  2. ThePrint, 'Disaster' film Niu Lai is a hit in China

  3. Al Bawaba, Choppy Chinese animated movie 'Niu Lai' garners $370,000

  4. X, Tong Bingxue's thread on Niu Lai's box office and reported budget

  5. The Hollywood Reporter, AI Feature Film 'Dreams of Violet' to Premiere at Tribeca

  6. Variety, 'Dreams of Violets' Review: What Does a Film Made with AI Look Like? B

  7. aiguan, 2026: Year One of China's AI Film Industry

  8. 36Kr, Is the AI Short Drama Industry Facing Cut-Throat Competition? Drive 5000% Growth by Going Overseas

  9. The Standard, Short AI films shake up micro drama industry

  10. invideo, AI Film Production Cost: What an AI Short Film Actually Costs to Make

  11. ImagineArt, Short Film Cost Breakdown: Traditional vs AI Filmmaking (2026)

 

Stay ahead in your financial journey! Sign up for our newsletter to receive insights, tips, and strategies from The Financial Coconut
,

Let us know what you think of this post